Talk:Beast Tamer Assistant, Keaton/@comment-25077685-20160309010624

Flaws I found on this card:

1.The wording. If the target area is not deck nor hand, instead of the word return, we use the word put. When a card is put into your soul...

2.The lack of "from (RC)". This makes the ability able to go off when you either soul charge from Magia, or when you pay the cost for Dragon Masquerade, Harri's skill. The wording should be this: When a card is put into your soul from (RC)...

3.The unnecessary. Once you pay this unit's cost, it is sent to the soul. And its ability cannot be used again anyway unless you call it from the soul back. And once you do that, the will be reset anyway, so you're able to use it again anyway with  if you call it back from the soul.

4.Combo with the flaw #2 I mentioned above. This card allows you to make an infinite combo. By having two copies of this unit on (RC). Once a soul charge ability from Magia occur during your main phase or battle phase, or when Dragon Masquerade, Harri's skill goes off, two copies of this unit can repeatedly alternating calling each other out from soul. Making an infinite call amount of number. Even though, you don't get any extra rear-guard benefit by doing so, let's take in this situation for a second: You have two copies of this unit on (RC), and your vanguard is Ardor Dragon Master, Amanda. Amanda's attack hits, Magia's Soul Charge (1), it triggers this unit's ability since the lack of "from (RC)". Keaton#1 goes to soul, Keaton#1 is called from soul, Keaton#2 goes to soul, Keaton#2 is called from soul, Keaton#1 goes to soul, and then it repeats to the infinite. Right now, there is only Silver Thorn, Upright Lion, and Barking Sky Tiger who have the ability to gain [Power] once a rear-guard is called from soul, and both of their conditions are specific. But, what if in the future, we have a clone of them, with Generation Break 1 instead of archetype or Legion condition? Yes, that unit's [Power] will get increased and increased until you're satisfied to the infinite. This is a serious flaw on this card, please take a moment to think on that. Especially goes worse in Extreme Fight format.

5.The wording should be "[Shield]+5000".